Final 5 – 4/29/08
Neil Diamond songs will really weed out the bad seeds. I’m thinking this is a nightmare waiting to unfold…..It’s good that they’ll each get to sing two songs.
1st Song -
Jason – Having his guitar saved him on this song. He did OK with what he had to work with and should be safe.
David Cook – A bit scary looking….especially when sitting next to Ryan who looks like Gumby tonight. He sounds just like a young Neil which should be just what he needs to go through tonight. Great job!
Brooke – If she only had more power in her voice. It looks like she’s more confident and knows all the words. I like the way she’s ending the song which makes you kind of forget the weak start.
David A. – He’s keeping his eyes open. The song’s OK but it lacks a connection. Too gumball sounding and not in a good way.
Syesha – I think she’s doing a fantastic job with this song. You don’t even think about it being a Neil Diamond tune. Just didn’t like the one high note in the middle that was a bit shout-y.
2nd Song –
Jason – I liked it but it seemed like he just wanted to get it over with. Not a strong finish and he’d better hope all his fans call in to vote.
David Cook – I can’t imagine Diamond singing this song which is good. I liked it but not as much as the first song.
Brooke – Ah …she didn’t have to look at the words on her hand. This may be her best song so far in this competition. She did great. Still may not carry forward.
David A. – He’s going to be even more amazing once his voice changes. What a fantastic song for him to sing. Truly a prodigy as Diamond stated.
Syesha – She could have picked the right song to finish out the night. First time I think she’s safe.
Have your bags packed Brooke and Jason.
This is really MOM posting - didn't realize Michelle was signed in on my computer.
No comments:
Post a Comment